Memory Wiki

I'll start by reading the Past Faults Log and understanding the full scope, then review each module and plan systematically.

Let me find the plan files more broadly.

Plans for T36-T42 don't exist yet. Let me now systematically review each module. I'll start by reading all the plan files for T26-T35, then examine each module's code.

Now let me examine the actual code modules.

Let me read the key module files for CSRF checking, migration interfaces, and test files.

Let me check the remaining modules and also examine the test files and migration classes.

Now let me check the migration classes and test counts for each module.

Now let me check PHP syntax on all modules and count test methods.

Let me check the services for FAULT-002 workaround documentation and verify the CSRF gaps.

Let me check the specific files in these modules for FAULT-002 workaround documentation completeness.

Let me do a final check on the plans directory for any T36-T42 related files and get a full listing.

Confirmed: no T36-T42 plan files exist anywhere. Now let me count the exact test numbers and write both review files.

Now let me write both review output files.

## Summary ### What I did 1. **Read the Past Faults Log** (`/root/.hermes/plans/past-faults-log.md`) to understand the 9 faults that must be checked 2. **Read all 8 build plans** (T26-T27, T30-T35) to establish expected behavior 3. **Read and analyzed all source code files** across 8 modules (102 PHP files total) 4. **Checked PHP syntax** on all files — all pass `php -l` 5. **Counted test functions** in each module — all exceed ≥12 minimum 6. **Verified migration classes** — all implement `\Profe\DbMigration\Migration\MigrationInterface` 7. **Checked CSRF enforcement** on every route 8. **Verified FAULT-002 workaround documentation** for all direct `profe_users` queries 9. **Searched for T36-T42 plans** — none exist ### What I found/accomplished **Code Review — 8 modules reviewed:** | Module | Verdict | Issues | |---|---|---| | T26 crm_tags | **PASS** ✅ | Clean — has `checkAuthWithCsrf()` pattern others lack | | T27 crm_sync | **PASS** ✅ | Clean | | T30 media_upload_jobs | **PASS WITH ISSUES** ⚠️ | POST `/api/media/upload` missing CSRF | | T31 media_progress | **PASS WITH ISSUES** ⚠️ | 3 POST endpoints missing CSRF | | T32 bunny_storage | **PASS** ✅ | Clean | | T33 bunny_stream | **PASS** ✅ | Clean | | T34 playlist_json | **PASS** ✅ | Clean | | T35 media_admin | **PASS** ✅ | Clean | **3 issues found:** - **T30**: `POST /api/media/upload` uses `checkAuth()` only (no CSRF). Plan requires CSRF=✅. - **T31**: `POST /api/media/progress`, `POST /api/media/progress/{mediaId}/complete`, `POST /api/media/progress/batch` all use `checkAuth()` only (no CSRF). Plan requires CSRF=✅ for all three. - Both modules lack a `checkAuthWithCsrf()` method (T26's CrmTagsModule has this pattern). **Plan Review — T36-T42:** - **0 of 7 plans exist** — all are MISSING. Cannot formally review. ### Files created 1. `/root/.hermes/plans/review-gs-final-t26-t27-t30-t31-t32-t33-t34-t35.md` — Code review with verdicts per task 2. `/root/.hermes/plans/review-gs-plans-t36-t42.md` — Plan review showing all plans missing ### Issues encountered - Plans for T36-T42 simply don't exist — they need to be created following the established pattern before code can be reviewed - The CSRF gaps on T30 and T31 are the most significant code quality issues found