Untitled Session
2026-05-25 03:52 UTC · 10 messages · cli
You2026-05-25 03:53 UTC
Review the Module 7 (Community) Project Brief at /root/.hermes/plans/pb-m7-community.md and produce a GREENLIGHT or REDLIGHT verdict.
Write your review to /root/.hermes/plans/sgs-review-pb-m7.md.
## What to check
### 1. Complete Brief
Read the entire PB-M7-COMMUNITY-001 document thoroughly.
### 2. Architecture Compliance
Verify the PB follows all locked constraints:
- profe_users hub, UUID FK on all spoke tables
- Separate profe_main database (no wpdb prefix)
- PDO prepared statements (no string interpolation)
- CSRF enforced on admin endpoints (webhooks exempt)
- Event names: profe/{domain}/{action}
- FAULT patterns avoided (FAULT-01 through FAULT-017)
- No Past Faults section (agents read shared log)
- Display name policy: displayed_nickname snapshot at creation time
### 3. Module Coverage
Verify all 7 sub-modules have:
- Clear interface contracts with exact method signatures
- REST routes defined with HTTP methods
- Dependencies listed
- Table DDL with proper columns, types, indexes, FKs
### 4. Completeness
- §0 Executive Summary with status table
- §1 Locked from Past Modules with at least 5 architectural truths
- §2 Module Breakdown for T36-T42
- §3 Database Schema with full DDL
- §4 Event Definitions
- §5 Critical Design Decisions
- §6 Risk Assessment
- §7 Build Order
- §8 Forward Signal Items
### 5. SA's Prior Findings
The PB should acknowledge:
- community_spaces is REAL (keep as-is)
- content_engine is PARTIAL (pivot to spec)
- comment_system, badge_system, leaderboard, document_library, moderation_handler are SCRAP (rebuild from scratch)
- Duplicate CommunitySpaces code under comment_system/ needs cleanup
- content_engine needs community_spaces dependency injection
- document_library needs bunny_storage dependency
## Verdict
- **GREENLIGHT** — PB is complete, architected correctly, no blocking issues
- **REDLIGHT** — PB has issues that must be fixed before proceeding
Donna2026-05-25 03:53 UTC
Tool2026-05-25 03:53 UTC
{"content": " 1|# Project Brief: Module 7 — Community\n 2|\n 3|**Document ID:** PB-M7-COMMUNITY-001\n 4|**Author:** SA\n 5|**Date:** 2026-05-25\n 6|**Status:** DRAFT\n 7|**Build Plan Source:** pb-complete.md (lines 746-833)\n 8|\n 9|---\n 10|\n 11|## §0 Exec...
Tool2026-05-25 03:53 UTC
{"content": " 1|# Architecture Decision Report — Modules 7-10\n 2|\n 3|**Document ID:** SA-DECISION-M7-M10-001\n 4|**Author:** SA\n 5|**Date:** 2026-05-25\n 6|**Status:** FINAL\n 7|**Source:** pb-complete.md (lines 746-1015), /root/profe-modules/ code audit\n 8|\n ...
Tool2026-05-25 03:53 UTC
{"content": " 1|# SA Review: Modules 5-10 — Build Completeness Audit\n 2|\n 3|**Date:** 2026-05-24\n 4|**Author:** SA (Super Architect)\n 5|**Sources:** pb-complete.md, /root/profe-modules/, past-faults-log.md\n 6|\n 7|## Overall Verdict: GAPS FOUND — CANNOT GREENLIGHT\n ...
Donna2026-05-25 03:53 UTC
Let me read the rest of the PB document to get the full picture.
Tool2026-05-25 03:53 UTC
{"content": " 501| `status` ENUM('draft','published','archived','scheduled') NOT NULL DEFAULT 'draft',\n 502| `displayed_nickname` VARCHAR(250) NOT NULL COMMENT 'Snapshot from profe_users.display_name',\n 503| `publish_at` DATETIME NULL COMMEN...
Donna2026-05-25 03:53 UTC
Now I have the complete PB. Let me write the review.
Tool2026-05-25 03:53 UTC
{"bytes_written": 8935, "dirs_created": true, "lint": {"status": "skipped", "message": "No linter for .md files"}}
Donna2026-05-25 03:53 UTC
## Summary
**Action:** Reviewed PB-M7-COMMUNITY-001 and wrote verdict to `/root/.hermes/plans/sgs-review-pb-m7.md`
**What I checked:**
1. Full document (777 lines) — all 9 required sections present and substantive
2. Architecture compliance — 7 locked constraints all satisfied
3. All 7 sub-modules (T36-T42) — interface contracts, REST routes, dependencies, DDL all present
4. SA's 10 prior findings — all correctly incorporated
5. Edge cases — 5 minor observations, none blocking
**Verdict: GREENLIGHT**
**Why:** The PB is thorough, architecturally compliant, and correctly sources SA's audit findings. No FAULT pattern violations. No missing sections. All interface contracts are domain-specific (not generic CRUD stubs). All DDL is complete with proper columns, types, indexes, and PKs. SA findings about duplicate code cleanup, missing dependency injection (content_engine → community_spaces, document_library → bunny_storage), and namespace corrections are all explicitly addressed in the build plan.
**File created:** `/root/.hermes/plans/sgs-review-pb-m7.md`