Untitled Session

2026-05-25 06:36 UTC · 15 messages · cli

You2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

Review all 3 TA build briefs for Module 8 (Forms). Write verdict to /root/.hermes/plans/gs-review-pb-m8-plans.md. Build briefs: - /root/.hermes/plans/task-t43-build-plan.md (Form Engine) - /root/.hermes/plans/task-t44-build-plan.md (Form Submissions) - /root/.hermes/plans/task-t45-build-plan.md (Form Admin) PB reference: /root/.hermes/plans/pb-m8-forms.md Past Faults: /root/.hermes/plans/past-faults-log.md For each brief check: 1. Interface matches PB spec 2. Architecture compliance (UUID FKs, PDO, CSRF, event naming, no FAULT violations) 3. Dependencies correct (Modules 2/3/4/5/6/10) 4. Migration DDL complete (proper columns, types, indexes, -- UP / -- DOWN) 5. Route definitions complete 6. Test plan adequate (≥12 tests) 7. Pipeline design feasible (T44) Per task: **APPROVED** or **NEEDS REVISION**

Donna2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

Tool2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

{"content": " 1|# T43 Build Plan — Form Engine\n 2|\n 3|**Module:** Form Engine\n 4|**Directory:** `/root/profe-modules/form_engine/`\n 5|**PB Reference:** PB-M8-FORMS-001, §2, §3.1-3.2, §4.1, §6.1, §6.5\n 6|**Migration files:** 053_create_profe_form_schemas.sql, 054_create_p...

Tool2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

{"content": " 1|# T44 Build Plan — Form Submissions\n 2|\n 3|**Module:** Form Submissions (replaces `form_entries`)\n 4|**Directory:** `/root/profe-modules/form_entries/` (scrap existing, rebuild as form_submissions)\n 5|**PB Reference:** PB-M8-FORMS-001, §2 (T44), §3.3, §4.2-4.3...

Tool2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

{"content": " 1|# T45 Build Plan — Form Admin\n 2|\n 3|**Module:** Form Admin\n 4|**Directory:** `/root/profe-modules/form_admin/`\n 5|**PB Reference:** PB-M8-FORMS-001, §2 (T45), §3.4, §4.1, Appendix B\n 6|**Migration files:** 056_create_profe_form_analytics.sql\n 7|\n ...

Tool2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

{"content": " 1|# Project Brief: Module 8 — Forms\n 2|\n 3|**Document ID:** PB-M8-FORMS-001\n 4|**Author:** SA\n 5|**Date:** 2026-05-25\n 6|\n 7|---\n 8|\n 9|## §0 Executive Summary\n 10|\n 11|Module 8 (Forms) is the membership funnel front door — every user...

Tool2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

{"content": " 1|# Past Faults Log — Profe Core Modules\n 2|\n 3|> **Purpose:** Every bug, design miss, and edge case discovered during development is recorded here.\n 4|> Future modules (and future TBs) MUST read this log before writing code.\n 5|\n 6|---\n 7|\n 8|## ...

Donna2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

Tool2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

{"content": " 501| },\n 502| \"pageId\": \"page_2\",\n 503| \"order\": 0,\n 504| \"options\": null\n 505| }\n 506|]\n 507|```\n 508|\n 509|### Pages JSON Object\n 510|```json\n 511|[\n 512| {\n 513| \"pageId\": \"page_1\",\n 514| \"title\": \"Your Info...

Tool2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

{"content": " 501| // d. Emit profe/form/payment_completed\n 502| // e. Resume pipeline from step 3 (create_wp_user)\n 503| // 4. Handle payment_intent.payment_failed:\n 504| // a. Find submission\n 505| // b. Update payment_status = 'failed',...

Tool2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

{"content": " 501|\n 502|```php\n 503|// In each mutation handler:\n 504|private function checkAdminAccessWithCsrf(): void\n 505|{\n 506| $this->checkAdminAccess(); // Verify user is admin\n 507| $this->csrf->requireValidNonce(); // FAULT-004: must call this\n 508|}\n 509|```...

Tool2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

{"content": " 501|| `process_payment` | `ProcessPaymentStep` | Create Stripe PaymentIntent via Module 3 `stripe_service->createPaymentIntent()`; store `payment_intent_id`; pause pipeline | Void PaymentIntent if not yet captured |\n 502|| `create_wp_user` | `CreateWpUserStep` | `wp_insert_user()`...

Donna2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

Now let me write the verdict file.

Tool2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

{"bytes_written": 14021, "dirs_created": true, "lint": {"status": "skipped", "message": "No linter for .md files"}}

Donna2026-05-25 06:38 UTC

## Summary **What I did:** Read and analyzed all 3 TA build briefs (T43 Form Engine, T44 Form Submissions, T45 Form Admin), the PB reference (pb-m8-forms.md), and past-faults-log.md. Applied 7-point checklist to each brief covering interface compliance, architecture, dependencies, DDL, routes, tests, and pipeline design. **What I found:** All 3 briefs are structurally sound and well-aligned with the PB, but each has spec-compliance gaps: - **T43 — NEEDS REVISION** (2 issues): Missing `changes` field in `schema_updated` event payload (PB §4.1); 3 extra events not in the PB event catalog - **T44 — NEEDS REVISION** (1 issue): Critical migration ownership conflict — PB §7.2 says T44 should create `profe_form_analytics`, but T44 delegates to T45's migration 056, creating a deployment ordering problem where `trackEvent()` will fail at runtime - **T45 — NEEDS REVISION** (3 issues): Event name `profe/form/admin/entries_exported` mismatches PB §4.1's `profe/form/entry_exported`; missing `format` payload field; missing Exception class definition (FAULT-017); migration ownership conflict shared with T44 **File created:** `/root/.hermes/plans/gs-review-pb-m8-plans.md` (14 KB, detailed verdict with all 7 checks per task, cross-cutting concerns, and ranked revision table) **Issues encountered:** The PB has an internal inconsistency between §2 and §4.1 regarding the entry_exported event naming (with vs without `/admin/` prefix). I resolved by treating §4.1 ("Full Event Catalog") as canonical.