Memory Wiki

I'll perform a thorough SGS Phase Gate review across all four modules and the migration files. Let me start with parallel checks.

Good — all three Module.php files exist and all four migrations exist. Now let me check each Module.php for `ModuleInstanceInterface`.

Check 1 PASSED — all three implement `ModuleInstanceInterface`. Now let me scan for FAULT-011 patterns (SQL injection via string interpolation).

The `->` in the regex is being parsed oddly. Let me search differently.

Good. Let me examine the potential SQL injection risk in FormEntriesRepository and also check the migration files, routes, pipeline steps, and Stripe webhook.

All migrations have proper `-- UP` / `-- DOWN` markers. Let me now check routes, pipeline steps, and the Stripe webhook handler.

Excellent. Now let me examine the route registrations and the Stripe webhook handler for signature verification.

Now let me verify the Stripe webhook handler's signature verification and the pipeline runner implementation.

Let me verify the StripeService actually implements signature verification.

Let me check the supporting pipeline classes and also do a spot-check on the individual step implementations.

Let me check the form_admin dependency declarations — they look like they have quadruple backslashes which might be an escaping oversight.

Let me verify whether the form_admin's backslash pattern is intentional or a compatibility issue by checking how the DI container resolves keys.

I notice the form_admin module uses quadruple backslashes in dependency strings while others use double. Let me verify the pattern by comparing with other modules.

Let me confirm the exact backslash count with a hex inspection.

Confirmed — form_admin uses 4 backslashes (`\\\\`) in the file which resolves to `Profe\\` in the string, while other modules use 2 backslashes (`\\`) resolving to `Profe\`. Let me check if other existing modules use the same pattern as form_admin.

Let me check one more module to confirm the standard backslash pattern used across the codebase.

I have a complete picture now. Let me write the verdict file.

Verdict written to `/root/.hermes/plans/sgs-phase-gate-m8.md`. ## Summary **VERDICT: REDLIGHT** I performed a thorough SGS Phase Gate review covering all 6 required checks across T43 (form_engine), T44 (form_entries/FormSubmissions), and T45 (form_admin). ### Passed (5/6): 1. **Module.php with ModuleInstanceInterface** ✅ — All 3 modules implement the interface correctly 2. **No FAULT-011 (SQL injection)** ✅ — All queries use parameterized placeholders; no raw string interpolation 3. **Migration SQL has -- UP / -- DOWN** ✅ — All 4 migration files (054-057) are well-structured with proper DDL 4. **Route registration** ✅ — 50 routes total across all 3 modules covering full CRUD, public submission endpoints, Stripe webhook, admin dashboard, export, analytics 5. **Pipeline runner (9 steps)** ✅ — Full Saga compensation pattern implementation with ValidateStep, ProcessPaymentStep, CreateWpUserStep, AssignMembershipStep, CreateSubscriptionStep, SyncCrmStep, SendNotificationsStep, TrackConversionStep, NotifyAdminStep 6. **Stripe webhook with signature verification** ✅ — Uses `\Stripe\Webhook::constructEvent()` (FAULT-013 compliant), handles `payment_intent.succeeded`, `payment_intent.payment_failed`, `checkout.session.expired` ### Failed (1/6): **DI container key mismatch in `FormAdminModule.php`** — The file uses quadruple backslashes (`Profe\\\\` → runtime `Profe\\`) in all 17 dependency/service key strings, while the rest of the codebase uses double backslashes (`Profe\\` → runtime `Profe\`). This means `$container->get('Profe\\\\FormEngine\\\\FormEngineInterface')` will fail because FormEngine registered as `Profe\FormEngine\FormEngineInterface`. This is a runtime-breaking issue. The fix is mechanical — replace `Profe\\\\` with `Profe\\` at all 17 occurrences in that one file. Once fixed, **GREENLIGHT**.